Renewal checklist

Your renewal went up. What should you do before you accept it?

Your renewal notice is not the final word. Before agreeing to pay more, take a look at your income estimate, enrollment deadline and the alternatives available to you.

Sam Jaber, licensed health insurance broker

Hi, I'm Sam Jaber, a licensed health insurance broker. Every fall, I talk with people who open their renewal notice, notice the higher price and aren't sure what to do next. I get it. But before you agree to pay more, there are a few things worth reviewing, and we can take care of most of them in one phone call.

Check your income estimate first

Your marketplace savings for next year depend on your income from the year before. HealthCare.gov explains that the previous year's income determines Marketplace savings for the following year. If your business did especially well, or your income went down, the savings shown on your renewal might not reflect what you will actually make. Update your application before accepting anything, so the price is based on a realistic estimate.

This is the easiest thing to check, but it's also something many people overlook. Your renewal might include more assistance than you should receive, or less than you qualify for. Looking at the income estimate behind it is how you find out.

Know your real deadline

November 1 is when open enrollment begins. To get coverage starting January 1, you must enroll by December 15. If you leave things as they are, HealthCare.gov may automatically enroll you again using an income estimate that no longer reflects your year. That's why I consider December 15 your actual deadline, regardless of the date shown on your letter.

Scenario 1 of 2

Your income still qualifies you for help

When your household still qualifies for a marketplace credit after reviewing your income, the marketplace is generally the best starting point for affordable coverage. But your renewal is just one available plan. Look at the other plans offered in your area during open enrollment before deciding to stay with the one that renewed.

Scenario 2 of 2

Your income is above the credit range and you are healthy

When your income is above the credit range, you pay the full renewal price without assistance. That makes comparing your options important. If you're healthy and paying full price, you can look at your marketplace renewal alongside a medically underwritten private PPO. The right choice depends on your medical history and the doctors you see, so we'll go through those details together instead of making assumptions.

You can still get a nationwide PPO

An increase in your marketplace renewal doesn't mean PPO coverage is no longer an option. I can help you apply for a nationwide PPO in all 36 states where I'm licensed. Consider the marketplace price as one part of the decision, rather than the whole decision.

What to do this week

  • Find your renewal notice and note the income estimate currently on your application.
  • Write down the doctors and prescriptions you currently use to compare them with any new plan.
  • Visit the carrier exits for 2027 hub and check your state to see whether your plan is leaving.
  • Get in touch with me before December 15, giving us enough time to review your choices and update the application if needed.

Where the figures on this page come from

  • Open enrollment starts November 1, and the last day to enroll for coverage starting January 1 is December 15 Source
  • If you do not act by December 15, HealthCare.gov may re-enroll you automatically, but you should update your application so your savings are right Source
  • HealthCare.gov uses the previous year's income to calculate Marketplace savings for the next year Source

Renewal questions I get

Straight answers, no sales pitch.

Should I just accept the renewal so I do not lose coverage?

If you accept without reviewing the details, you could end up with a price that doesn't reflect your income. If staying with your current plan is your preference, confirm the deadline and check that your application uses the right estimate. Reviewing your options doesn't mean you have to give up your coverage.

Can I change plans after the renewal arrives?

Yes. You can review other plans and switch during open enrollment, so you're not locked into your renewal. For coverage beginning January 1, the deadline is December 15.

What if my plan is leaving the marketplace?

Start by going through your notice carefully, then visit the exits page for your state. Not sure whether your plan appears there? Give me a call, and I'll check before you decide what to do.

Is a higher renewal always a reason to switch?

Not necessarily. After looking at the alternatives, you may find that the higher renewal is still the right price. What matters is comparing your choices before deciding to switch.

Send me the renewal before you accept it

Send me your renewal notice along with your income estimate. I'll look at the offer against your other options and explain exactly when your deadline falls.

Keep reading

Guides by line of work and by state