Health insurance for therapists and counselors

Here's how therapists in private practice are saving money on their health insurance this year

Going solo means your caseload is yours, and so is your health plan. Here is how therapists and counselors in private practice are keeping that cost under control this year.

Sam Jaber, licensed health insurance broker

Hi, I'm Sam Jaber, a licensed health insurance broker. I'm based in Tampa, I'm licensed in 36 states, and every conversation happens by phone, so it doesn't matter where your office is or whether you see clients over telehealth from home.

Therapists and counselors make up a growing share of the people who call me. Most of them spent a few years at an agency, a group practice or a hospital program, got fully licensed, and then opened a practice of their own. The freedom is real. So is the moment you realize the group plan stayed behind with the old job.

You spend your days helping people think through hard decisions, so I'll keep this one simple. There's one question that sorts out most of it, and then a handful of situations. Find yours below.

The question that points you in the right direction

Here it is: is your household income likely to be under the subsidy line for the coverage year?

That line is roughly four times the federal poverty level. A single person reaches it at a little over $60,000 a year, and each additional person in the household raises it.

Lots of solo clinicians sit close to that line, which is why this question matters so much for you. And because you're self-employed, the figure that counts is your net income from the practice: what's left after rent, your EHR and billing service, liability coverage, continuing education and the rest. A full caseload can still leave you under the line once those come out.

Scenario 1 of 4

I expect to be under the line this year

Then the marketplace is usually where you'll pay the least. Subsidies only apply to marketplace plans, and for a counselor near the line they can bring the premium down a long way.

The hard part is the estimate. A private practice income moves with cancellations, the weeks clients take off around the holidays, and how long insurance panels take to pay you. You enroll on what you expect to make, and if you end up earning more, the difference is settled on your tax return. You could owe part of the subsidy back. The healthcare.gov guidance for uneven income is to report your best current estimate and update it as things change, and that's what I'll help you do.

Scenario 2 of 4

My income is over the line and my household is healthy

Above the line, nobody helps with the price. You can still buy a marketplace plan, but at full cost it often feels out of proportion to how little care a healthy household uses.

So I show healthy clinicians a second option: private plans outside the marketplace that are medically underwritten. You answer health questions on the application, and the insurer decides whether to accept you and on what terms. For applicants in good health, that can mean a noticeably lower price than the marketplace's full rate.

These plans are built on PPO networks that cover the country, so you aren't limited to one local network. That's useful if you split time between two places or have family in another state.

Because acceptance rides on your health answers, a past diagnosis can lead to a decline or an exclusion, so we go over everyone's history honestly before applying. Benefits also vary between plans, and I'll walk you through what any plan you're considering actually pays for.

Scenario 3 of 4

One of us has a condition that needs regular care

You know as well as anyone that ongoing care, whether it's a chronic illness, a mental health condition or a daily prescription, has to keep going without interruption. If someone on your plan is in that spot, the marketplace is usually the safer home, even if you're over the subsidy line.

Marketplace plans have to accept everyone and can't charge you more because of your health. An underwritten plan can turn an applicant down or exclude the condition they need covered most. So we stay on the marketplace and choose the plan where you live that keeps your providers and prescriptions in network.

Scenario 4 of 4

I just left an agency or group practice

When an employed position ends, its health plan usually ends with it. That loss gives you a special enrollment window, generally 60 days, to pick a marketplace plan outside open enrollment. If you're on COBRA, note that canceling it early by choice doesn't open that window, so we plan the switch rather than rushing it.

Your first year of private practice is also hard to forecast. You might be building a caseload slowly, or you might bring clients with you and fill up fast. We'll weigh both paths against the year you're most likely to have.

A nationwide PPO is still available to you

In some places the marketplace offers only HMO or EPO plans, and in others its PPO costs more than most people can stomach. That isn't a dead end. If you're healthy, I can quote you a nationwide PPO in every state where I'm licensed, all 36 of them. A short call is all it takes to see the price.

What makes our first call quick

Nothing is required, but these help:

  • Last year's tax return, or a rough sense of what the practice netted
  • Who needs coverage
  • Your zip code
  • Any providers or prescriptions you want to keep
  • The end date of your current plan, if there is one

Working with me doesn't cost you anything. I'm paid by the insurance company when you enroll, and your premium is the same either way.

Questions therapists in private practice ask me

Straight answers, no sales pitch.

Can I deduct health insurance premiums as a solo practitioner?

In many cases, yes. The self-employed deduction is capped at the practice's net profit and doesn't apply to months you could have joined an employer plan, including a spouse's. Your tax preparer can confirm it for you.

My caseload changes month to month. How do I estimate income for the marketplace?

Use your best estimate for the year based on recent months and last year's return, then update it with the marketplace whenever your income shifts. Updating promptly lowers the chance you'll owe money back when you file.

I left a clinic job. How long do I have to enroll in a new plan?

Losing job-based coverage usually gives you 60 days to enroll in a marketplace plan. If a private underwritten plan suits you better, apply early, because approval takes time.

Can a therapist in private practice get a PPO?

Yes. For healthy applicants earning above the subsidy line, private plans built on PPO networks that reach across the country are something I can quote in all 36 states where I hold a license.

Tell me about your caseload and your household

Roughly what your practice netted last year, who needs to be on the plan, and any providers you want to keep. That's enough for me to tell you which way to go and what it costs, and if what you have now is right, I'll tell you that.

By state

Therapists in private practice in your state

Health insurance by occupation

Other lines of work I help